William Hay – Quote mined scientist denounces Quran miracle claims

16:45

21 Nov 2011

Miracles / Ijaz, Environment

TheRationalizer

William Hay

This vlog presents the Rationalizer discussing quotes (from the mid 1980s) attributed to William Hay  about the divine nature of the Qurʾān.  Hay, an oceanographer, was asked questions about Qurʾānic interpretations (in the 1980s) regarding ocean currents, material which he indicates was well known among fisherman and seaman before Muḥammad’s time.  They do not indicate what verses Hay was asked to interpret.

The Rationalizer seeks to put early quotes frequently reused in Muslim materials on iʿjāz into context.  He has vlogs with other speakers who are also often quoted on YouTube.

Evaluation:

There is no mainstream Muslim group that holds that women have no souls.  Although Hay seems to attribute it to the Taliban, for the vast majority of Muslims anywhere the statement would be absurd.

There is little science here beyond general statements Hay makes about ocean currents.  That the facts were known in the 7th century already is also clear.  However, it is unlikely that either proponents or opponents of iʿjāz would be able to prove what Muḥammad did or did not know.  These are better addressed as questions of faith for believers.