Islamic Civilization and Astronomy
18 Sep 2012
Astronomy, History of Science
George Saliba, professor of Arabic and Islamic science at Columbia University, New York, discusses the role(s) played by science in the medieval Islamicate world. He sets out to debunk two myths about “Islamic science” — that it only carried forward Greek scientific ideas, and that “modern science” was created sui generis in Europe during the Renaissance.
To debunk these ideas he discusses “the critical role of Arabic astronomy” in the development of Renaissance science. He discusses the role of astronomical observation in determining the time for the daily prayers, citing verses 2:232-238 of the Qurʾān. Mathematical developments were needed in order to determine the time for the afternoon prayer. He discusses how 9th century Baghdadi Muslim scholars realized the problems with Ptolemy’s observational strategies, and developed their own methods for determining the solar apogee. The other problem that needed to be worked out in relation to prayer was determining the direction of prayer. This required spherical geometry and computing latitude and longitude lines. Scholars also tried to develop new projections of maps with Mecca at the center in order to assist pilgrims to determine how far they would need to travel for the ḥajj to Mecca. As they moved through Greek geometry, they started to correct the factual and theoretical problems they found that did not match their observations. Ibn al-Haytham wrote “Doubts on the Works of Ptolemy” to try to bring together physics and mathematics. Saliba points out the similarities between Ibn al-Shatir’s solutions to the size of the moon and those of Copernicus (d. 1543). ʿUrdī (d. 1266, Damascus) also creates models (“the ʿUrdī Lemma”) that are similar to those of Copernicus. Saliba pointedly suggests that Copernicus copies Ibn al-Shatir’s models, even without quite understanding them. He also demonstrates similarities between a model developed by Nasīr al-Dīn al-Ṭūsī (d. 1274) and those of Copernicus. He wraps up his discussion by noting that the algebra that had been developed in the Islamic world wasn’t uniformly picked up in Europe. For instance, Galileo didn’t seem to use Islamic algebra.
Saliba closes by saying that it’s important to try to extract the development of scientific ideas from the “cultural bragging”, both from Europeans and Muslims.
Concepts discussed: trigonometry, development of astronomical instruments to measure the motion of the stars (including that of Ulugh Beg in the 15th century), rotation of spheres on their axes, mathematics of spheres, Ibn al-Shatr (d. 1375) on the size of the moon, Nasīr al-Dīn al-Ṭūsī (d. 1274) and planetary motion
The lecture was given at the Library of Alexandria, Egypt, on the occasion of the 20th meeting of the International Planetarium Society. This keynote lecture was delivered on 29 June 2010.
The material on Islam is within the bounds of what Muslims have historically understood as acceptable.
The material on the history of science is based on well-researched materials. The correspondences in the models, one must note, need not necessarily mean that a later scholar extracted the information from an earlier scholar, although it is possible. Additional work on the dissemination of the Arabic scientific material among European scholars may help us understand more completely the transferences among these scholars.
About George Saliba
George Saliba received a Bachelors of Science in mathematics in 1963 and a Masters of Arts in 1965 from the American University of Beirut. He went on to pursue a Masters of Science degree and a doctorate in Islamic Sciences from the University of California, Berkeley. In 1978, Saliba started his teaching career at Columbia University in New York as a professor of Arabic and Islamic Sciences. He has received many awards, most notably the History of Science Prize in 1993 and the History of Astronomy Prize in 1996. Saliba was a Distinguished Senior Scholar at the Kluge Center of the Library of Congress (2005-2006) and at the Carnegie Scholars Program (2009-2010).
Saliba’s studies are described on his website as “the development of scientific ideas from late antiquity till early modern times, with a special focus on the various planetary theories that were developed within the Islamic civilization and the impact of such theories on early European astronomy.” His website provides a link to his most recent research in addition to a listing of his publications. A portion of his public lectures may also be found online at the 1001 Inventions website.
George Saliba does not appear to operate any social media pages as of 2015. He served as an advisor for the Science and Islam Video Portal project.
“George Saliba.” MESAAS. Columbia, n.d. Accessed 21 May 2015.
“George Saliba.” Wikipedia. Wikimedia Foundation, n.d. Accessed 21 May 2015.
“Professor George Saliba Lectures | 1001 Inventions.” Professor George Saliba Lectures | 1001 Inventions. 1001 Inventions, n.d. Accessed 21 May 2015.
Saliba, George. “Saliba’s Page.” Saliba’s Page. Columbia, n.d. Accessed 21 May 2015.